• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
Pawesome Cats helping cats live happy, healthy lives

Pawesome Cats

helping cats live happy, healthy lives

  • Home
  • Cat Health
  • Cat Behaviour
  • Life with Cats
  • Raw Feeding
  • Cat Breeds
You are here: Home / Raw Feeding / Homemade vs Commercial Raw Food Diets for Cats

Homemade vs Commercial Raw Food Diets for Cats

By Pawesome Cats | Updated on 26/12/2022

28 shares
  • Share
  • Tweet
  • Email

Once you’ve made the decision to transition your cat to a raw food diet, you’ll need to consider which type of raw food will best suit you and your cat.

There are essentially two options: you can purchase a pre-packaged commercial raw food or prepare your cat’s meals from scratch yourself in your home kitchen.

Commercial Raw Food Diet for Cats

Pre-packaged commercial raw food is usually frozen in portion sizes, which you can defrost as and when you need it. Whilst commercial raw food can be an expensive way to feed your cat a raw diet, for the busy working pet parent it’s a quick and easy option. It really is as simple as just opening a packet of food and transferring the appropriate portion amount into your cat’s bowl.

Advantages

  • If you’re a little squeamish or ‘put off’ by the thought of handling meat, offal and bones – you don’t have to.
  • Commercial raw food generally contains all of the nutrients and other essentials that your cat needs for a healthy, balanced diet – so you don’t need to add additional supplements.

Disadvantages

  • You often have to buy commercial raw pet food in large quantities, so if you’re only just starting the transition to raw feeding and your cat won’t eat this particular brand or product, you’re stuck with it.
  • A commercial raw food diet is often very soft (we’ve seen products that resemble baby food), so it doesn’t work your cat’s jaw or teeth unlike chewing on raw meaty bones or meat chunks.

Charlie has IBD, so when I starting feeding a commercial raw food diet it was important to me to pay close attention to the list of ingredients. Surprisingly, I discovered a few raw food products claiming to be suitable for ‘dogs and cats’, but which included onion and garlic (known to be toxic to cats) or yoghurt (which can cause issues for cats that are lactose intolerant). My advice is to read the labels and ensure you know exactly what you’re feeding your cat, especially if they have gastrointestinal problems or other health issues. It’s better to be safe than sorry!

Homemade Raw Food Diets for Cats

A homemade raw food diet is made up of raw meat – in chunks or ground, offal and raw bones (chicken necks, for example). Preparing your cat’s food from scratch is likely to be less expensive in the long run, but it can be time consuming in the beginning.

RELATED:  How to Transition Your Cat to Raw Food Step-By-Step Guide
Different methods of feeding homemade raw - grinding, frankenprey and whole prey | Commercial Versus Homemade Raw Food Diets for Cats
Image: toholio via Flickr

 

The two factors that generally dissuade people from preparing raw food from scratch are:

  1. Being ‘squeamish’ about preparing raw meat or handling offal.
  2. The process seems complicated and expensive – you need to work out the right balance of raw food and nutrients, and include supplements.

For the first six months after transitioning the cats to a raw food diet, I fed them commercial raw food – it was easier and the idea of preparing raw food from scratch seemed overwhelming. As someone who eats mostly chicken or vegetarian meals myself, I’ll also freely admit that I wasn’t keen on handling raw meat or organs. I’ve since learnt to appreciate that the only way to really know what is in the food the Pawesome Cats family are eating, is to make it myself from scratch.

Ground Raw Food Diet

This is probably the most popular method of feeding raw and works well for cats that transition from a commercial wet food (canned) diet. It involves putting the meat (including offal, bones and fat) into a meat grinder with supplements and egg yolk to make a ground food for your cat. Overall, this is a cost effective option but you’ll need a powerful meat grinder to grind the bones, so there may be some initial expense.

Different methods of feeding homemade raw - grinding, frankenprey and whole prey | Commercial Versus Homemade Raw Food Diets for Cats
Image: Anfuehrer via Flickr

 

Raw feeders who follow a ground raw food diet for cats usually make large batches of food and freeze it in meal-sized portions. The main downside of a completely ground raw diet is that it won’t have enough texture to keep your cat’s teeth and jaw strong and healthy, but you can add chunks of raw meat to address this.

RELATED:  How Much Does It Cost to Feed Raw Cat Food? [2023]

Prey Model or ‘Frankenprey’ Raw Food Diet

The prey model diet is designed to closely resemble your cat’s diet in the wild, with the correct percentage of animal parts – meat, organs, edible bones and muscle meat fed in controlled quantities over a week. The basic guide is 80% muscle meat, 10% bone, 5% liver, and 5% other secreting organ. Each meal or day may include different species of animal, hence the alternative term ‘frankenprey’.

Meals are usually chunks, which your cat will need to gnaw on until they are bite-sized. One of the benefits of the prey model diet is improved dental health – the process of having to tear and gnaw at meat and bones will keep your cat’s mouth healthy and teeth tartar free.

There is generally less preparation and fewer supplements involved than the grinding method of feeding raw but it can be time consuming to calculate the correct proportions and determine the supplements required to ensure this diet is nutritionally balanced. Raw feeders who follow the prey model raw food diet usually stick to strict feeding programs.

Whole Prey Raw Food Diet

Whole prey is exactly what it says – feeding your cat whole prey animals rather than butchered meat. People who feed their cat this type of diet cite that it’s easy to feed, although for some people, it can be an emotionally difficult decision to feed whole animals.

Different methods of feeding homemade raw - grinding, frankenprey and whole prey | Commercial Versus Homemade Raw Food Diets for Cats
Image: mararie via Flickr

 

Outdoor cats who are familiar with hunting prey are more likely to take to this type of diet, whereas indoor cats that have been fed canned food most of their lives and never caught prey before won’t recognise what you’re giving them as a source of food or know what to do with it.

RELATED:  Easy Homemade Raw Cat Food Recipe

Do you feed your cat a raw food diet? What’s your preferred method of feeding raw?

Top image: Boaz Arad via Flickr

Different methods of feeding homemade raw - grinding, frankenprey and whole prey | Commercial Versus Homemade Raw Food Diets for Cats

SaveSave

28 shares
  • Share
  • Tweet
  • Email

Filed Under: Raw Feeding

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Jennifer Haden says

    26/08/2015 at 6:30 pm

    This is an excellent post. I can’t believe how horrible the ingredients are in commercial cat foods. It makes sense if we clean up our own diets, to clean up our pets, they deserve the best nutrition also x

  2. The Daily Pip says

    13/08/2015 at 11:33 am

    We just transitioned our dog to a raw diet and are now preparing to do the same thing with the cats. I think we probably will go with a commercial raw since there are so many good ones on the market and time (or lack of time) is an issue for us.

  3. Jean Dion says

    13/08/2015 at 7:19 am

    I fed Eamon, my cat, a raw diet for many years. But he was the only one of my crew that would even touch the stuff. The girls tried to bury it, run from it or kill it. That made the house quite a mess, I gotta say. And, then Eamon decided he wouldn't eat it anymore, either.

    Many raw diets just don't smell like anything, and I wonder if that lack of scent put Eamon off his meals. Now that he's a senior, he seems to like foods that are higher on the stink level. That's just a guess, of course.

  4. Robin says

    13/08/2015 at 6:10 am

    It is really interesting to see all of these aspects of raw cat food! I think that if I started feeding raw I would start out with a commercial diet with the end goal of doing a grinding diet. If I could afford to buy anything in bulk, feeding raw would be a much more realistic idea for me. I'm sure my kitties would like it once they got used to it.

  5. Kitties Blue says

    12/08/2015 at 10:04 pm

    I've never fed raw. Never even heard about it until I started blogging. With eight cats and limited freezer space, I would be making food constantly. Have any studies been conducted to determine cats are healthier and live longer on a raw diet?

  6. Sometimes Cats Herd You says

    12/08/2015 at 10:03 am

    The head peep was researching what it would take to make raw for us, but we have very little freezer space, so that's not practical right now. It seems like some people would feed commercial raw not only because they are squeamish about grinding but because storage space for a big enough batch to make the effort worthwhile might not be available.

    • Maxwell, Faraday & Allie says

      14/08/2015 at 10:16 am

      True, that. And the time. Mom's time is soooo constrained right now. She was thinking about ground bu you're right about the teeth issue. It would be AWESOME if some company would come up with a supplement you could add to ground raw and – presto – balanced diet!
      Yeah, she's looking for an easy way out MOL!

  7. Lola The Rescued Cat says

    12/08/2015 at 9:57 am

    We have never tried raw food. Mommy things she may be a little squeamish and probably couldn't do it. I have to say, it would probably fun to catch a real mousie some day!

  8. The Island Cats says

    12/08/2015 at 9:52 am

    Maybe one day when the mom has more time, she'll start making raw food for us.

  9. Rosa @ Cat Lady Confidential says

    12/08/2015 at 6:02 am

    I must confess I never considered feeding my cat raw food. Canned food is very convenient and my cats loves it. In Portugal I never saw pre-packaged commercial raw food. I don't think we have it here.

  10. Connie says

    12/08/2015 at 4:59 am

    the down side to frakenprey is that if you have multiple cats you might end up with cats who don't eat appropriately.

    I have one of my cats who won't chew meat. period. she certainly will not chew bone. She's amazing because her teeth are pretty clean so it is working for her, but I have to grind to ensure even distribution of nutrients to the whole crew.

  11. Ellen Pilch says

    11/08/2015 at 11:34 pm

    I would love to feed raw, but I am squeamish and I was worried about the cost of feeding 15 cats. I also worry I would mess up the supplement part and they would lack taurine. etc.

  12. Layla Morgan Wilde (Cat Wisdom 101) says

    11/08/2015 at 9:54 pm

    Lots to think about. I'm curious if you have access to more or better quality meat in AU.? In the U.S. buying organic is expensive and we are a culture of convenience. I admire your dedication to feed and prep your own raw which is a cat's ancestral diet. We feed a combo of raw, grain-free wet and dry only as treats (when I don't have time to make my own).

  13. Summer says

    11/08/2015 at 2:46 pm

    We aren't currently eating any raw, but I think it would be cool to have some raw meat and bones to chew on! I chew on the paper plates my canned meals are served in, so my human thinks I do have a need to gnaw on something.

Primary Sidebar

  • Instagram
  • Pinterest

Latest Blog Posts

ginger kitten with arched back and upright tail on grass lawn

8 Reasons Why Cats Arch Their Backs

25/07/2023

coconut in shell with ground coconut and oil

Coconut Oil for Cats: Is It Good or Bad?

18/07/2023

tabby cat standing in blue litter box

What Does It Mean When a Cat Can’t Pee? 

11/07/2023

ginger and white cat with curved tail

Why Do Cats Wag Their Tails?

04/07/2023

tabby white cat eating from white bowl tongue out

Why Is My Cat Always Hungry? 10 Possible Reasons

27/06/2023

newborn kitten with eyes closed in human hands

Fading Kitten Syndrome: How To Recognise The Signs

20/06/2023

ginger cat digging in litter tray

Is Your Cat Allergic to Litter? How to Tell

13/06/2023

close up of ginger cat sneezing

Why Is My Cat Sneezing? 10 Possible Reasons

04/06/2023

Footer

Disclaimer

All articles are based on our personal opinion and experiences. Information on this site should not be considered a substitute for professional veterinary advice, care and treatment. If your cat is unwell and you are concerned for any reason, please contact your veterinarian immediately. Unless otherwise credited, all images and content are copyright to Pawesome Cats.

Affiliate Disclosure

Pawesome Cats is a member of affiliate programs that provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to products sold online including the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program. As an Associate the owner of this site earns from qualifying purchases. For more information, refer to our Disclaimer page.

Privacy

This site may collect anonymous demographic information when you visit our site, click on a link or leave a comment. For more information, read our privacy policy.

Quick Links

About   |   Contact   |   Subscribe

Copyright © 2023 Pawesome Cats - All Rights Reserved.

28 shares